Sunday, June 13, 2010

What happened to my TV ?

Before the era of liberalization, India was a sleepy nation which had few choices in terms of cars, scooters or Television (Ambassador, Bajaj Chetak or good old DD). As reforms kicked in, the standard of living has improved and so has the choices increased. As economists state as competition increases, competitiors have to differenitiate on quality and so it is better for customer. Right?

Wrong at least in Indian Television, I feel things have taken a turn for the worse. Earlier, we had Doordarshan which is played versatile role of entertainment with shows like Hum Log, Buniyaad, comedy like Flopshow, Dekh bhai Dekh and informative shows like Turning Point and Surabhi. The sheer range of programming was fantastic. True, DD benefited from a monopoly of being the only broadcaster in the country so the finest talent had only one platform to showcase their skills.


Circa 2010 :

We have 130+ news channels and several General Entertainment channels; definitely a viewer’s delight and advertisers’ misery on which TV channels and spots to target to maximize eyeballs. The focus has shifted to formula driven TV rather than being a creative platform to educate and entertain the audience.


General Entertainment Channels

One day, I surfed through Colors, Starplus, Sahara One, Zee TV, Sony and Imagine. Just shows about well dressed Saas-bahu soaps with dramatic music. So I got bored, I thought I will follow music channels, MTV, Channel V and UTV Bindass, what do I see young wannabe in reality shows who have learnt the choicest of expletives. You cannot follow much except the BEEP BEEP BEEP. Apparently market research by some firms have convinced target segment for GEC are only housewives or college going youth who want 2 mins of fame.


News Channels


New channels are no less, all of them will follow the exact same breaking news; A channel will claim an exclusive interview with Hillary Clinton, within 15 mins other channel will run an interview with the same celebrity; did people forget the definition of exclusivity? The Hindi channels keep running clips of film stars, wrestler Khali and TV stars who I don’t know at all. The hindi news channels are pathetic to say the least and the English media is pretentious and is ever cynical and prying on the negatives of each story. As a journalist, the focus is not bringing out facets of a story but only pick out the titillating crude aspects which have shock value. My most hated TV news anchor is Arnab Goswami, his modus operandi, get a large panel and he keeps talking all the time. He pushes his personal opinions down the viewers’ throat with smugness and screeching tone. He asks Lalit Modi “please touch your heart and tell us the truth”, ya right, Lalit is going to tell us the truth on prime time (Hopeless). The only news channel which has some credibility left is NDTV 24x7, Barkha, Dr Roy and Vikram Chandra still hold out some hope yet for Indian TV journalism.


Television today has become victim of TRP/TAM ratings syndrome, TV channel owners are ready to accept blindly the ratings/research of certain media agencies; thus they are appealing to the least common denominator of the audience; there are islands of viewers who’s sensibilities and interests which are going a begging. Today’s TV cannot hold a candle to the enduring icons of yesteryears like Jaspal Bhatti, Pankaj Kapoor or Girish Karnad or characters like Karamchand, Rajini or Mungrilal. Today its about hype and less about enduring legacies.


Hoping for a better Television viewing until then I remise about the good old days of DD when Fauji, Circus, Nukkad, Mahabharat, Giant Robot and Star Trek ruled the roost.



7 comments:

  1. Panelists !!! Please do not speak when Arnob is interrupting.
    It is bad manners. :D

    You should try out X-News, minimum frill news (I fear they are also NDTV subsidiary)
    Anything English worth watching on TV is either NDTV or ex-NDTV. They however are unfortunately too pro-UPA, they should be neutral. But center-of-right might not agree with their view-points.

    Also the lack of quality in vernacular news-TV-agency is very disturbing, because thats what works outside of big cities. People in Saharanpur watch Hindi news not English, hence that should be of non-"Manufacturing Consent" quality.

    http://vikramvgarg.wordpress.com/2010/02/22/indian-language-news-channels-and-the-expansion-of-democratic-space/

    ReplyDelete
  2. totally agree with you dude.........dunno wat has happened to the good old days of meaningful and realistic programming.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well Written Dude

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks guys for your comments - yes TV programing in the name of TRP is either focusing on sensationalism, there is no objective reporting at all. even entertainment channels offer little cheer.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good one G!!! Enjoyed reading it!!! Esp "pl touch ur heart and tell us de truth"..... :):)

    In addition to de Saas-bahu soaps in entmt channels... Teleshopping scores high in testing our patience!

    ReplyDelete
  6. dude now now... its a little chicken and egg situation.... trouble is India largely remains a single tv household and the rmote lies with the lady of the house...youngsters 18-35 only flirt with television they are more glued to other mediums internet, i phones, movies etc etc... every channel which innovated with content aimed and came to please the tg I and u fall in soon had to fire employees and shut shop or get acquired...the answer lies in what u have written itself one day you surfed after that one day u will be like the mumbai rains. the house wife on the other hand for whom we make our shows are loyalists they come every evening and hence it is their command we choose to please. In other words, at 18-35 age we find ourselves amongst a minority and as always in our country rights and choices of the minority are marginalized! Its the same reason why no body wants to mass market sugarless ice cream or dark chocolates in this country!:( govind

    ReplyDelete
  7. @ Govind - yea i know thats problem in being middle class youth :) u have no reservations, you are not a good votebank, we are too fragmented to fight corruption or even have a TV channel of choice ! venting in blogs and downloading seasons of english sitcoms is the only solution

    ReplyDelete